What dozens of candidates and employers told us when we showed them the designs for the new Hatch, led by their excitement for two-way matching.
I get nervous if we build for too long without checking in with customers. It’s the risk that we make decisions that feel sensible internally, but have a big blind spot that is only discovered when real users jump in.
So, over the past two weeks I’ve been talking to dozens of Hatch users - both candidates and employers - to get feedback on how the product upgrade is shaping up.
I’ve been showing users the designs of the new end-to-end journey (what we call our “red routes”). It’s been very open-minded research that’s sought feedback on:
General reactions and any blind spots we haven’t thought of
What are the magical moments in the red routes that users are most excited for
New product terms and concepts – do they make sense?!
To give you an inside scoop, I thought I’d share some of the insights from those conversations (warts and all!).
The top area of feedback was how excited users are for a new way to match.
In particular, people liked the more-equal power balance that’s established by two-directional matching: an employer can request to match with a candidate, or a candidate can request to match with an employer. This is a key part of the platform upgrade.
This is what a match request sent from an employer to a candidate (proactive sourcing) looks like in the new product:


There is a lot of excitement for moving away from traditional transactional job applications, and towards person-to-person matching on platform.
One candidate I spoke to said it felt “very different to other application processes on Seek and Indeed that I've done to the point of boredom. It’s really clever. I feel like, because you get that immediate response from them accepting a match, that's really smart.”
Another said “I like the immediacy of it. I like that you can immediately get it into a conversational mode. That's good.”
An employer told us they really liked it, especially for gen Z candidates. "I like that it’s a ‘match request’ - feels like candidates get a faster response and better comms."
What also came through very strongly from managers was loving the ‘one stop shop’ nature of the page where they would have access to both inbound requests and proactive sourcing for a job. They told us this would save them time and mean a better experience for them and candidates.
We were also worried that the idea of a ‘match’ might not be totally understood but so far, so good. There will be work to do in educating everyone how the product works but this was very relieving! Phew.
After hours and hours of interviews I consolidated all the feedback we received from our community. Here’s the short summary I shared with our team:

I personally loved hearing everyone’s excitement for the rich content about managers and candidates, for example team reels where a team member answers a few 20-30 sec questions about what it’s like to work in their team.
And just because we’re getting to know each other now… a moment that made me laugh was when one of our amazing candidates was asked about a certain bit of copy on our marketing site. She said it might resonate “if I'm like, 40 and in a midlife crisis.” I won’t be sharing how old I am.
They were several areas identified where we’ll need to work hard over the coming months to make sure the user experience is smooth. For example – ATS and employer workflow integrations, and ease of team members adding rich content.
But really, this research has given me more conviction than ever that #hatchfromscratch is going to be a huge step forward for both candidates and employers in finding great matches. And I’m super excited for you all to get in there in the coming weeks!